A recent study was done and published in the journal Lancet
Psychiatry regarding the various brain differences between violent offenders
and non-offenders. The study compared a group of people who were all convicted
of a violent act who were also diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder
and psychopathy. The other portion of the group were violent people who had
antisocial personality disorder, but not psychopathy, and the remaining
individuals were those with the disorder but not offenders. Similar to the
method James Fallon took when looking at the brain scans for some lawyers whose
client has murdered several people. Through PET scans they were able to get a
functional representation of the brain activity of the murderer and compare it
to a "healthy" brain. In the study they used a functional MRI which
serves a similar purpose.
Fallon found that there was a “decrease of activity in the orbital
cortex and the area around the amygdala” (Fallon 45). These areas are normally
responsible for preventing impulsiveness, so in the case of the murderer’s
biology he was unable to control himself. In court this argument allowed for
the accused to have his sentence changed from the death penalty to life in
prison without parole. Fallon dealt with several more psychopathic killers who’s
brain scans show clear abnormalities and were not “just impulsive killers but
real methodical psychos” (Fallon 45).
Alexandra Sifferlin explains in her Time article, Violent
Psychopaths Don’t Register Punishment, Study Says, that the results from the study with the fMRI showed that there
were noticeable differences in the white and grey matter between
non-psychopathic criminals and non-offenders. These areas correlate to areas of
the brain which encompass our emotions such as guilt and moral reasoning. Also they
found abnormalities in the regions connected with empathy which in the case of
non-psychopathic criminals showed a lack of.
The purpose of the study and what I believe Fallon is trying to
get at is that if we are able to catch these signs of abnormal brain
development or characteristics of psychopathy in young children we have a much
higher chance of intervening and preventing them to go on to perform violent
acts. The goal of the authors who were in charge of the study are to develop a
program for parents to place their children in case of them showing early
onsets of psychopathic characteristics.
Link to
Article: http://time.com/3685596/psychopaths-brain-punishment/
References:
Fallon, J. (2013). The
psychopath inside: A neuroscientist’s personal journey into the dark side
of
the brain. New
York: Current.
Sifferlin, A. (2015). Violent Psychopaths Don’t Register
Punishment, Study Says. Time.
No comments:
Post a Comment